When Spirituality Becomes An Excuse

I've been quiet about Russell Brand for the past week.

Not because I've had nothing to say. Quite the opposite.

I've been struggling with what I've seen on Facebook, particularly from people within the yoga and spiritual communities.

The conspiracy theories. The declarations of forgiveness. The insistence that he's a different man because he's found Jesus. The sympathy for the fact that he's going to prison.

And now I've seen people posting smiling photographs of themselves with him, sending him love and receiving sympathy because someone they admired has been found guilty of rape and sexual assault.

And I've had enough.

HE HAS BEEN FOUND GUILTY.

Not accused. Not the subject of a rumour. Found guilty.

And yet people are still finding ways to make him the victim.

I'm a survivor of sexual assault.

More than once, by different men. Some of what happened to me was over forty years ago.

And yes, reading these posts has been triggering.

But I want to make something very clear.

I don't hate Russell Brand.

I don't want to give him that much space in my head.

I'm glad he's been held accountable. I'm glad he's going to prison.

I'm thinking about the women.

What they went through. What they've lived with since. What it might have been like to see his face on television, to hear his sexual jokes, to watch him being celebrated and admired.

I'm thinking about their families, their relationships and their futures.

And I'm thinking about something else.

It's not just the women he assaulted who are reading your posts.

It's every woman who has experienced sexual violence.

Every woman who has spent years wondering whether she should have reported what happened to her.

Every woman who has never told another living soul.

Every woman who was assaulted recently and is frightened to speak up.

According to the World Health Organization, nearly one in three women worldwide has experienced physical or sexual violence by an intimate partner, or sexual violence by someone else.

And in England and Wales, more than one in four women has experienced sexual assault, including attempts, since the age of sixteen.

Think about that.

Women you work with. Women you teach. Women you call friends. Women in your own family.

Women whose experiences you may know absolutely nothing about.

And they're opening Facebook and seeing people sympathising with a man who has been found guilty of rape.

They're seeing people suggesting conspiracies, questioning the justice system, celebrating his redemption and telling everyone not to judge.

If this is how people respond when a man has actually been found guilty, what message are we sending to women who haven't reported what happened to them?

What reason are we giving them to believe they'll be treated with compassion if they come forward?

And you may never know how many of those women are reading your words.

Then there's the spiritual justification.

"But he's found Jesus."

"He's a different person now."

"Let he who is without sin cast the first stone."

Are you fucking kidding me?

Finding Jesus doesn't erase rape.

Getting married doesn't erase rape.

Having children doesn't erase rape.

Becoming a different person doesn't erase rape.

His transformation does not rewrite the women's histories.

And here's something else.

YOU DO NOT GET TO FORGIVE SOMEBODY ELSE'S RAPIST.

You can pray for him. You can believe in redemption. You can hope he's changed.

But you cannot forgive him on behalf of the women he assaulted.

That forgiveness isn't yours to give.

I do not forgive the men who sexually abused me.

And I don't have to.

That doesn't make me less compassionate, less spiritual or less healed.

It means that decision belongs to me.

And please stop treating forgiveness as a badge of spiritual superiority.

I also want to say something about justice.

Justice and healing are not the same thing.

A prison sentence does not erase rape.

It doesn't undo what happened. It doesn't give someone back the years before it happened. It doesn't magically remove the consequences.

A survivor may feel enormous relief when justice is served.

But that doesn't mean everything is suddenly all right.

And the perpetrator finding religion or rebuilding his life doesn't change what he did.

Then there are the conspiracy theories.

Apparently, some people believe Brand has been targeted because he challenged powerful institutions.

Well, if you're suggesting that women fabricated allegations as part of an elaborate conspiracy, you'd better have some actual evidence.

Because repeating a conspiracy theory isn't discernment.

And questioning authority doesn't automatically mean defending a powerful man.

Perhaps we should be asking how celebrity, influence and power can make it so difficult for women to report sexual violence in the first place.

And yes, I feel compassion for his family. They haven't committed these offences. They may be suffering terribly because of his actions.

But I do not feel sorry for him because he's facing the consequences of what he's done.

I've watched people turn his imprisonment into a philosophical discussion about whether he's a good person or a bad person, whether justice has been served, whether he deserves compassion and whether he might reinvent himself.

And all I can think is:

WHAT ABOUT THE FUCKING WOMEN?

What about their lives?

What about their futures?

What about the women reading these posts who have experienced sexual violence themselves?

You don't have to know a woman personally to care that she's been raped.

And you don't have to hate the man responsible to recognise the seriousness of what he's done.

I've spent over twenty years teaching yoga. I believe in compassion. I believe in the possibility of human change. I believe in the value of philosophy.

But I do not believe that compassion means abandoning accountability.

I do not believe that non-judgement means refusing to recognise violence.

And I certainly do not believe that forgiveness is something we can offer on behalf of somebody else.

And your capacity to forgive does not give you the authority to forgive on behalf of someone else.

The women are not supporting characters in Russell Brand's redemption story.

They are human beings with lives that matter independently of whatever happens to him next.

And if you're a yoga teacher publicly defending him, perhaps consider that some of the women reading your words may be survivors themselves.

You may never know.

I've been quiet for a week.

I'm not going to be quiet anymore.

Previous
Previous

Clutch Your Fucking Pearls Somewhere Else