Clutch Your Fucking Pearls Somewhere Else

I’ve tried to let this go. I really have. But the more I read and hear about the public reaction to Russell Brand’s conviction for rape and sexual assault, the angrier I become.

Apparently, men are frightened now.

Frightened they might be falsely accused. Frightened a woman might come forward twenty years later. Frightened their sons might be next.

I’ve even seen a man saying he’s advised his son not to flirt with women in nightclubs.

What the actual fuck?

A man has been convicted of rape and sexual assault. Not falsely accused and exonerated. Convicted.

A jury heard the evidence, convicted him on four counts and acquitted him on three.

So where has this sudden panic about false accusations come from?

An accusation is not a conviction. An acquittal is not proof that an accusation was false. And a conviction doesn’t become a miscarriage of justice simply because the offences happened decades ago.

Of course false accusations can happen. Of course innocent people deserve protection. But why are we suddenly making that the central conversation following a rape conviction?

And now apparently twenty years is too long.

There should be a statute of limitations, some are arguing.

Why?

If someone committed murder twenty years ago, would we suggest they should escape prosecution because time had passed?

Historical evidence must be scrutinised carefully. That’s why we have courts, legal representation, juries and the requirement to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

But twenty years isn’t an amnesty for rape.

And let’s not forget who we’re talking about here.

Russell Brand wasn’t just some bloke down the road. He was a hugely famous celebrity, with money, influence, powerful connections and an enormous public following.

Can you imagine how intimidating it might be to accuse someone like that of rape or sexual assault?

The fear that nobody would believe you. The fear of what might happen if you spoke out. The prospect of your private life being dragged into public view while thousands of strangers defended the man you were accusing.

And then, twenty years later, you finally speak.

Only to discover that the very fact you waited is now being used as a reason to question you.

Do you see the fucking irony?

The judge himself recognised that Brand’s status had helped protect him for years.

Perhaps instead of asking why these women waited so long, we should be asking what made it so frightening for them to speak sooner.

And here’s something else worth remembering.

I got married in 1991.

The very same year that the law in England and Wales finally recognised that a husband could rape his wife.

That’s not ancient history. That’s my adult lifetime.

For generations, women have fought to be treated with dignity when reporting sexual violence.

We’ve fought against the idea that a woman must have done something to invite it.

That her clothes mattered.

That drinking alcohol made her responsible.

That her sexual history somehow determined whether she could be raped.

We’ve fought against the shame, the disbelief, the humiliation and the appalling treatment women have sometimes experienced when seeking justice.

And we’ve fought to help people understand why a woman might not report sexual violence immediately.

Because sexual violence is profoundly personal. Because shame and self-blame can be devastating. Because fear of not being believed can silence someone for years.

Sometimes decades.

Sometimes forever.

And while we're asking why women don't immediately report rape or sexual assault, perhaps we should consider what we're actually expecting of them.

A woman who's just been raped isn't necessarily sitting there thinking, "Right, I'd better preserve as much forensic evidence as possible in case I decide to take this man to court."

She's potentially in fucking shock.

She may be frightened, confused, numb, physically hurting or desperately trying to understand what's just happened to her.

One of her first instincts might be to wash. To shower. To get clean. To try to reclaim some sense of control over her own body.

And yet we're expecting her to think about preserving evidence, going to the police, undergoing intimate examinations and recounting something profoundly personal to complete strangers.

All while she may be questioning herself.

Did I say no loudly enough?

Should I have fought harder?

Was it somehow my fault?

And then, twenty years later, somebody asks why she didn't report it immediately. Why there's no forensic evidence. Why she waited so long.

Do you understand how fucking unreasonable those expectations can be?

We are judging a woman's response to a traumatic experience against what might have made a criminal prosecution easier years later.

She wasn't thinking about securing a conviction.

She may have been struggling simply to get through the next ten minutes.

And perhaps that's something we should try to understand before we start questioning why she didn't behave the way we think she should have.

And now we’re publicly rehearsing every bloody reason women have ever been frightened to come forward.

According to the Office for National Statistics, approximately one in four women in England and Wales has experienced sexual assault or attempted sexual assault since the age of sixteen.

One in four.

And yet, following a man’s conviction for rape and sexual assault, we’re being invited to direct our sympathy towards men who are frightened that they might one day be falsely accused.

And to the father who’s apparently told his son not to flirt with women in nightclubs…

Seriously?

Women have spent generations being warned about what they wear, where they go, how much they drink, who they trust and whether it’s safe to walk home alone.

And now you’re frightened your son might have to think about how he behaves around women?

Instead of teaching your son to fear women, teach him about consent, boundaries and respect.

Flirting isn’t rape. Being rejected isn’t a false accusation. And respecting a woman’s boundaries isn’t something to be frightened of.

Perhaps consider what your daughters have been taught to fear their entire lives.

But here’s what frightens me far more than all these men clutching their pearls about hypothetical false accusations.

Somewhere, a woman may be reading this.

A woman who has never told anybody what happened to her. A woman who has spent years carrying something she never asked to carry.

She might be your daughter. Your sister. Your mother. Your friend.

She might finally have been thinking about speaking up.

And then she sees the comments.

The disbelief. The accusations of lying. The demands for a statute of limitations. The sympathy for a man convicted of rape and sexual assault.

And perhaps she decides she simply cannot face it.

Perhaps she decides to stay silent.

And perhaps the man who assaulted her is never held accountable.

That’s what frightens me.

Not the hypothetical possibility that an innocent man could be falsely accused, but the very real barriers that prevent women from reporting sexual violence in the first place.

Every time we turn a conversation about sexual violence into a conversation about how frightened men should be, we risk making it that little bit harder for another woman to speak.

And if you cannot see the damage that might do, perhaps you need to think about whose fear you’re choosing to take seriously.

Because she’s listening too.

And if your first response to a rape conviction is to make yourself the potential victim, clutch your fucking pearls somewhere else.

Next
Next

When Spirituality Becomes An Excuse